
Is your common property not being maintained to the standard you expect? Are cleaning and maintenance issues continually being raised, but little seems to change?
These are common frustrations for body corporate committees, particularly when disagreements arise over what the caretaker or building manager is actually responsible for.
A Caretaking Performance Review (Common Property Condition Report) provides an independent assessment of the property’s condition against the Caretaking Agreement, helping committees identify deficiencies, clarify responsibilities and take appropriate action.
Your Caretaking Agreement Could Run for 25 Years. Is Your Property Getting the Attention It Deserves?
In Queensland, some caretaking agreements can run for up to 25 years. During that time, buildings age, maintenance requirements change and management rights may be transferred to different caretakers.
But one thing remains important: the common property should be maintained in accordance with the Caretaking Agreement.
For owners, their property is both a home and a significant financial investment. When cleaning standards slip, gardens become neglected or routine maintenance is overlooked, the appearance, enjoyment and long-term condition of the property can suffer.
And when the committee and caretaker disagree about the required standards, these issues can continue for months or even years.
So how do you know whether your caretaker is actually fulfilling their obligations?
That’s where an independent Caretaking Performance Review can help.
Why Do Caretaking Disputes Arise?
Most caretaking agreements outline the caretaker’s responsibilities, including cleaning, gardening, routine maintenance and the general upkeep of common property.
However, disagreements often arise over how these duties are interpreted, how frequently work should be undertaken and what constitutes an acceptable standard.
Common concerns include:
- Stairwells, corridors, car parks and other common areas not being cleaned properly.
- Gardens, lawns and hedges appearing neglected or overgrown.
- Blown light bulbs, damaged fittings and minor repairs left unattended.
- Pool areas, recreational facilities and common property furniture not being maintained.
- Maintenance concerns repeatedly reported but not addressed.
- Disagreements about whether certain tasks are the caretaker’s or body corporate’s responsibility.
In many cases, the committee believes the caretaker is not fulfilling their obligations, while the caretaker considers the work satisfactory or outside their contractual duties.
Without an independent assessment, these disagreements can become ongoing disputes, with neither party agreeing on the required standard.
The challenge is establishing what the agreement actually requires and whether those duties are being performed.
You’re Paying for a Service. Is It Being Delivered?
Body corporate caretaking agreements can involve significant ongoing expenditure, with owners contributing towards the services provided.
In return, the body corporate expects the agreed duties to be undertaken in accordance with the contract.
This doesn’t mean every surface must be spotless at all times or that every maintenance issue is automatically the caretaker’s responsibility.
Cleaning and gardening conditions naturally change between scheduled service intervals. Major repairs, capital works and specialist maintenance may also fall outside the caretaker’s contractual obligations.
However, recurring deficiencies, neglected areas and outstanding routine maintenance can raise legitimate concerns.
A professional assessment helps distinguish between reasonable conditions arising between service intervals and potential failures to meet contractual requirements.
What Is a Caretaking Performance Review?
A Caretaking Performance Review is an independent inspection and assessment of common property conditions against the relevant Caretaking Agreement.
At Olive Tree Consulting Group, we begin by reviewing the agreement, including the schedules of duties, service frequencies and maintenance responsibilities.
Our qualified consultants then conduct an onsite inspection of the scheme, assessing the accessible common property against the relevant contractual obligations.
The review helps establish:
- Whether the relevant caretaking duties are being undertaken.
- Whether cleaning, gardening and maintenance standards are satisfactory.
- Which areas require attention or corrective action.
- Whether identified issues fall within the caretaker’s responsibilities.
- Which matters may instead require body corporate approval, specialist contractors or capital works.
Our findings are documented in a detailed report, supported by photographic evidence and references to the relevant contractual duties.
Our objective is simple: establish the facts, remove uncertainty and provide a clear basis for improvement.
Going Beyond Traditional Reports with Interactive 360° Inspections
One of the biggest challenges with traditional common property condition reports is identifying exactly where an issue has been observed.
For example, a report might state that a light fitting is not working, a hedge requires trimming or a stairwell needs cleaning.
But which light? Which hedge? Which stairwell?
These questions can lead to unnecessary correspondence, confusion and delays in addressing the findings.
See Exactly Where Each Issue Is
At Olive Tree Consulting Group, our in-house 360° reporting technology allows us to virtually document the inspected common property and tag findings directly to their locations.
Instead of relying solely on written descriptions and individual photographs, committees, caretakers and legal advisers can virtually navigate the property and see exactly where issues have been identified.
Our interactive reports include:
- 360° Virtual Inspections: Explore common property areas from our inspector’s perspective.
- Location-Specific Findings: See exactly where each issue has been identified.
- Extensive Photographic Evidence: Review multiple supporting photographs where necessary.
- Contractual References: Understand which caretaking duties are relevant to the findings.
- Detailed PDF Reporting: Access a professional report alongside the interactive inspection.
We place considerable emphasis on photographic documentation, providing extensive visual evidence to support our findings.
This added visibility helps reduce confusion, improves communication and makes it easier for everyone involved to understand what requires attention.
How Can a Performance Review Help with a Remedial Action Notice (RAN)?
Where caretaking concerns remain unresolved, a body corporate may consider issuing a Remedial Action Notice (RAN).
A RAN is a formal notice that identifies alleged failures or breaches and requires the caretaker to take specified corrective action within the applicable timeframe.
However, the notice must clearly identify the alleged failures and relevant contractual obligations.
General statements such as “the gardens are not maintained” or “the car park is dirty” may not adequately explain the concerns.
This is where a detailed, independent Caretaking Performance Review can assist.
Clear Evidence for Lawyers and Committees
Our reports identify observed deficiencies, document their locations and reference relevant duties within the Caretaking Agreement.
The interactive 360° inspection provides additional visual evidence, allowing legal advisers to review findings in their property context.
For example, rather than simply referring to a dirty stairwell, the report can identify the particular stairwell, level and location, with supporting photographs showing the observed condition.
This level of detail can assist legal professionals in assessing alleged breaches, preparing a RAN and identifying the corrective actions required.
It can also reduce disputes about the location or nature of reported issues.
Importantly, the preparation and issuing of a RAN should be undertaken with appropriate legal advice to ensure the relevant legislative and contractual requirements are met.
What Happens If the Matter Proceeds to QCAT?
Not every caretaking dispute is resolved through discussions or remedial action.
Where matters escalate to the Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal (QCAT), clear documentation and reliable evidence can become particularly important.
A Caretaking Performance Review provides an independent record of the property’s observed condition at the time of inspection.
Our detailed photographic evidence, contractual references and interactive 360° reporting can help legal professionals understand and present the relevant findings.
Rather than relying solely on correspondence, committee complaints or isolated photographs, parties can refer to a structured assessment identifying the location and nature of the reported issues.
While no report can guarantee a particular legal outcome, clear and properly documented evidence can assist in assessing and presenting a case.
An Independent Assessment for Both Parties
A Caretaking Performance Review isn’t about taking sides.
Olive Tree Consulting Group provides independent assessments for bodies corporate, committees, caretakers and legal professionals.
We recognise that some deficiencies may arise naturally between scheduled cleaning or maintenance activities, while others may involve responsibilities outside the caretaker’s agreement.
Our role is to review the relevant contractual obligations, inspect the property and report our findings objectively.
Where corrective works have subsequently been completed, follow-up inspections can also be arranged to document the updated condition of the property and review whether previously identified matters have been addressed.
Ultimately, the aim should be to improve the condition and management of the property, rather than allow disagreements to continue unnecessarily.
Don’t Let Caretaking Issues Become an Ongoing Dispute
When common property concerns continue without resolution, frustration can build and relationships between committees and caretakers can deteriorate.
For schemes operating under long-term caretaking agreements, allowing these issues to continue can affect the presentation, maintenance and enjoyment of the property for years.
An independent assessment can help establish a clearer understanding of the property’s condition, the caretaker’s contractual responsibilities and the matters requiring attention.
Whether the objective is to improve maintenance standards, clarify disputed duties or obtain evidence for formal remedial action, a professional Caretaking Performance Review provides a practical way forward.
Need an Independent Caretaking Performance Review?
Olive Tree Consulting Group provides Caretaking Performance Reviews and Common Property Condition Reports across Queensland and Northern NSW.
Our qualified consultants combine detailed agreement reviews, onsite inspections, extensive photographic evidence and interactive 360° reporting to help bodies corporate, caretakers and legal professionals understand the issues and work towards a resolution.
Contact our team to discuss your scheme or request an obligation-free quote.
Office: 1300 142 172
Email: admin@olivetreeconsultinggroup.com.au



